i'm hooked on a theory

It's Tuesday, and in my world, very little occupies my thoughts except for that of LOST. Pathetic, sure, but since we're in the final stretch, I see no harm in appealing to my inner geek and enjoying these last moments.

Anyway, I wanted to just briefly give anyone who cares a piece of what I'm thinking about, in regards to the final season, but specifically to Jacob and his friend.

SPOILERS AHEAD, NATURALLY...

Good and Evil seems to be the buzz words when it comes to these two folks, but in last week's episode, we saw that both of these guys deemed the other one "Evil", or "The Devil." This struck me as fascinating, and definitively proved that this isn't about good and evil, in the absolute sense.

I'm reminded of the season 2 premiere title, "Man of Science, Man of Faith", an episode that highlighted the struggle Jack has with Locke's blind faith in his "destiny" and in the Island's powers. As we've seen, Jack has slowly become a man of faith, someone who just last season, took the biggest leap of all and tried to explode a hydrogen bomb, in order to reverse the past and make their lives better by never having their plane crash. Locke however, had his faith fail him countless times, ultimately leading to his death, and to him becoming the face of the Smoke Monster.

So, here's what I'm thinking: this conflict is key to the show. It has been since season one. So, instead of good vs. evil, I wager the show is presenting a much more interesting approach: Faith vs. Reason. Here's why:

Jacob - He's an enigma. He speaks only through Richard Alpert, who as we've learned, was also not privy to everything. He asks only that those who follow him learn for themselves what they must do. They know they are special, having been given a gift, but in the end, they have to figure it out on their own. He leaves things unanswered on purpose, so that people like Jack can learn on their own.

MIB - Smokey takes a different approach: he's forthright. He spells it out like it is, almost over-simplifying things. He promises results in exchange for discipleship, and his arguments are sound, and reasonable. He holds little back.

I think when Jacob was saying that The Island keeps "evil" from pervading the world, he wasn't talking about demons, or monsters, but rather an overflowing of Reason. Reason teaches us so many wonderful things, through science and philosophy, but what would happen if Reason was to pervade our world on a massive scale? What would happen if EVERYTHING was spelled out for us, and we knew all the answers? I think we'd all be asking ourselves "So, what now? What's left to believe in?"

I think belief and faith is something crucial to human existence, whether it's in God, or Buddah, or Allah or even whether it's faith in Science. Scientists have faith, believe it or not. It may be a more secular faith, but it's faith nonetheless. They believe that Science can prove all the mysteries of the world, even though they can't see it, they believe it. If Scientists had all the answers, what would be left? Our understanding would be complete, and Science would become fact and life would be, well, boring.

The Island governs that balance. It keeps Reason at bay, allowing men to discover for themselves how to be men, and how the world functions. It promotes the need for faith, for belief. But, as it is a balance, Reason still is allowed to exist, for it is as necessary as faith.

What's interesting to realize is that while Faith is the enemy of Reason (which is why MIB was so dead set on killing Jacob), Faith has no reason (ha!) to despise the idea of Reason, because without Reason, there can be no understanding, and isn't that what we are all seeking? Understanding? Jacob wants his followers to understand, but he doesn't want it all spelled out, because then what's left to learn? Jacob needs that balance, or else he's done for.

It's a balance. It's like the Cave of Names and the two rocks. One without the other is chaos, either a world of blind faith without reason, or reason without the ability to learn for one's self.

Also, look at it another way: Jacob believes men are good, and he's desperate to prove that to MIB, while MIB believes men are inherently evil, capable of terrible things even without negative influence. That seems to further emphasize the varying belief systems of these two individuals: If men are good, then they don't need all the answers to make a better world, but if they're evil, then you need to spell it out for them to help them make the best decisions.

So, essentially, the Island serves as the ultimate place of understanding. All the answers are there, everything we could ever want to know about The World. But, with Jacob as its ruler, those answers are kept hidden from the Island's inhabitants, allowing them to discover the answers for themselves. With Jacob gone, the world is in danger of losing faith, and becoming all knowing, if MIB were to leave. To the MIB, that's a wonderful thing, because there are no secrets, no blind following of mystical entities. In his mind, the world is better off understanding itself than constantly questioning itself.

Jacob brings people to the Island to keep trying to prove to the MIB that it's better for him to be imprisoned and locked away on the Island, but he's been failing. The men keep killing each other off, proving, in a sense that without the influence of Jacob, men will still be evil. Now, enter Richard Alpert, who introduces the notion that maybe Jacob's approach is flawed; if they don't know to follow Jacob, how can they not listen to Reason, the only other voice on the Island? So, Richard begins to gather castaways, with the help of Jacob, and we get The Others, the indigenous folk who help Jacob to guide his "candidates", fully aware that one day the MIB will kill him (for he knows all, right?).

Now, this only accounts for the Jacob/MIB thing, not the time travel, Jughead, Dharma Initiative, Flash Sideway stuff. That is all still a mystery to me, but I for one hope they connect to my theory.

So, there you go.

Probably a lot of hokum, I know. But, what else you gonna think about when you can't sleep? There's so much more to this story, that I'm half-convinced this is wrong, but I like to believe it anyway. It's what makes the show so much fun; it means so many different things to so many different people. And, I think it'll remain relatively ambiguous all the way to the end. We'll get our answers, sure, about the Island, and where exactly these two fellas came from, but apart from that, why would we want to know more?